May 21, 2024
OWASP Top 10 Essential Tips for Securing LLMs: Guide to Improved LLM Safety
- LLMs
- LLM Security
- Generative AI
May 21, 2024
Today, large language models (LLMs) are the driving force behind many digital tools we use every day, from customer service chatbots to smart assistants that help us write emails. However, as these models grow in importance, they bring significant security challenges ranging from the spread of misinformation to the potential for data breaches and malicious content manipulation.
OWASP, or the Open Web Application Security Project, is a nonprofit foundation that improves software security through community-led open-source software projects, tools, documents, forums, and chapters. The OWASP Top 10 for LLMs is an essential guide that offers developers, cybersecurity experts, and AI researchers a structured approach to identifying and mitigating these vulnerabilities.
OWASP's Top 10 LLM list not only highlights the necessity of securing LLMs but also lays out a roadmap for maintaining application integrity and safeguarding user privacy and safety. Making LLMs secure goes beyond merely preventing cyber threats; it's about creating a reliable and safe environment for all users interacting with these technologies.
This article explores practical steps and strategies from the OWASP Top 10 to safeguard your LLMs, maintain application integrity, and protect user privacy.
If you need a TL;DR, here’s a table summarizing the ten tips and their most important points:
The most important overall takeaway is that securing LLMs requires a comprehensive, multi-layered approach that addresses potential vulnerabilities at every stage of the LLM lifecycle, from data sourcing and model training to deployment and ongoing monitoring.
Now, let’s get right into these tips! 🚀
Tip 1: Safeguard against prompt injection
Imagine if, by simply tweaking their request, someone could make your AI do things it shouldn't—revealing secrets or making unwanted decisions. This is the threat of prompt injection, a critical vulnerability within LLMs where malicious inputs exploit the AI's processing capabilities.
Examples of prompt injections include:
- Direct prompt leaking: Tricking the AI into revealing internal configurations or sensitive data.
- Indirect prompt injections: Embedding commands within normal-looking inputs to make the LLM perform unintended tasks.
- Stored prompt injections: Embedding malicious content in saved data that triggers harmful actions when referenced later.
- Context-blending attacks: Mixing harmful instructions with standard requests to hide malicious intent within normal queries.
An LLM-driven customer service platform could be tricked into disclosing personal information or performing unauthorized actions. An attacker might craft a seemingly harmless question designed to coax the AI into accessing and sharing sensitive user details or carrying out specific commands like changing user account settings without permission.
To guard against prompt injection, implement strategies such as:
- Privilege Control: Limit the LLM’s capabilities to necessary tasks to reduce the risk of unintended actions.
- Input Validation: Closely examine all inputs for unusual or risky data points and filter out suspicious requests. Consider techniques like whitelisting, blacklisting, and data sanitization.
- Content Segregation: Compartmentalize the LLM’s interactions to prevent external content from influencing core operations.
- Trust Management: Maintain healthy skepticism about AI inputs and outputs. Implement human oversight where necessary.
Tip 2: Ensure secure output handling
What comes out of your LLM can sometimes end up in the wrong hands or places, causing anything from minor embarrassment to major security breaches. Just as you would meticulously proofread a document for sensitive information before making it public, ensuring the safety of AI outputs demands thorough checks.
For instance, if AI-generated text directly influences backend systems without checks, it might do something harmful, like running unauthorized commands. Or, if an AI creates web code (like JavaScript) that gets sent to users without security checks, it could lead to attacks in the user's browser.
By rigorously validating and sanitizing all AI-generated content (consider techniques like blacklisting and whitelisting), you can prevent harmful data from slipping through. Additionally, restrict the potential actions these outputs can trigger based on user permissions and security context. This ensures outputs remain useful, secure, and protect users and systems.
Tip 3: Prevent data and model poisoning
The adage "garbage in, garbage out" holds particularly true for AI. Feeding low-quality data to your LLM, such as outdated, incomplete, erroneous, or biased information, can lead to biased, inaccurate, or harmful outputs.
Data poisoning, where attackers deliberately contaminate your model's training data, directly undermines the integrity of LLMs, potentially leading them to produce biased or misleading text.
For instance, imagine a competitor feeding false product reviews into your model's training set, which would lead your LLM to generate inaccurate product recommendations.
To combat this, focus on two key safeguards:
- Rigorously verify and validate data sources: Ensure the sources of your training data are legitimate and maintain a record to trace data back to its origins. Implement regular audits, filters, and checks (like anomaly detection or schema validation) to maintain the integrity of your LLM training. Consider maintaining a record similar to a Software Bill of Materials to trace data back to its origin.
- Employ sandboxing and diverse datasets: Test data and models securely, preventing access to dubious sources. Diversifying your training datasets can help mitigate the impact of tainted data and promote more balanced and accurate outputs.
Tip 4: Protect against model Denial of Service (DoS) Attacks
Denial of Service (DoS) attacks against LLMs aim to overload the system, making it unavailable to users who need it. Attackers might flood your AI with complex queries or a high volume of tasks, causing the system to slow significantly or even halt. This disrupts service for legitimate users and increases operational costs.
Example: An attacker repeatedly requesting the generation of extremely long text sequences could exhaust the LLM's resources.
To defend against these attacks:
- Implement rate-limiting:
- Implement rate-limiting mechanisms to control the number of requests per user or client.
- Set appropriate thresholds based on your system's capacity and expected usage patterns.
- Use algorithms like token or leaky buckets to enforce rate limits and prevent abuse.
- Set resource limits:
- Limit the resources (e.g., CPU, memory, GPU) allocated to each query or task.
- Monitor resource usage in real time and enforce limits to prevent individual requests from consuming excessive resources.
- Implement graceful degradation mechanisms to maintain system stability when resource limits are reached.
- Manage action queues:
- Prioritize and manage the queue of incoming requests to ensure fair processing and prevent the system from getting bogged down.
- Implement load-shedding techniques to drop or defer low-priority requests during periods of high load.
- Use asynchronous processing and background tasks to offload computationally intensive operations and maintain responsiveness.
Note: These defenses often necessitate adjustments to your infrastructure, such as using load balancing or web application firewalls.
Tip 5: Address supply-chain vulnerabilities
Just as in manufacturing, where a faulty part can compromise an entire product, vulnerabilities in any component of an LLM's supply chain can pose significant risks. This includes everything from the data used to train models to the plugins and extensions that enhance functionality.
To address these risks, take a comprehensive approach:
- Source vetting: Carefully evaluate models, data sources, suppliers, and package repositories for trustworthiness.
- Security testing: Conduct vulnerability scans throughout development and deployment. Implement adversarial robustness tests to check for tampering and train against sophisticated extraction attempts.
- Code integrity: Enforce code signing and secure development practices.
- Ongoing oversight: Maintain diligent oversight with regular reviews and audits of supplier security practices.
You can keep your LLMs reliable and secure by staying vigilant and enforcing strict checks.
Tip 6. Design secure plugins with care
Plugins are a powerful way to extend the functionality of LLMs, but they can also introduce significant vulnerabilities if they are not designed and implemented securely.
Improperly managed permissions in plugins can lead to data leaks, unauthorized access, and other security issues that can compromise the integrity and trustworthiness of the LLM.
To avoid such issues, implement the following:
- Strict authorization: Define clear authorization requirements for all plugin actions, especially those handling sensitive data.
- Data compartmentalization: Reset plugin-supplied data between calls to prevent data from being mistakenly used by another plugin.
- Monitor data flow: Closely monitor data flow within the system to prevent unintended data usage.
You can protect sensitive information and maintain LLM security and trustworthiness by controlling data access and sharing.
Tip 7: Minimize sensitive information disclosure
LLMs can sometimes share sensitive information without meaning to, from personal to proprietary data. Preventing this starts with tight controls on how LLMs handle and share data. This means programming models to anonymize and protect user information and ensuring they're smart enough to avoid revealing anything they shouldn't.
Key actions include:
- Data sanitization and validation: Thoroughly sanitize and validate data to catch and clean any sensitive information before use in training or responses. Consider techniques like differential privacy for greater robustness.
- Supply chain security: Monitor the supply chain, using security testing and verification to patch vulnerabilities that might expose data.
- User awareness: Educate users on safe interactions with LLMs and communicate data handling policies transparently.
Adopting these strategies creates a safer environment that guards against unintended information leaks from your LLM.
Tip 8: Limit excessive agency in LLMs
Allowing LLMs too much freedom in decision-making and actions can lead to significant risks. This issue, known as Excessive Agency, can result in LLMs executing unintended commands or actions.
To safeguard against this, take the following steps:
- Minimize permissions: Grant LLMs only the necessary permissions to perform their intended tasks.
- Implement action limiting: Restrict the number of actions an LLM can perform within a given time frame.
- Enforce human oversight: Require human review and approval of critical LLM actions, maintaining control over operations.
Tip 9: Avoid overreliance on LLMs
While LLMs can perform many tasks with remarkable efficiency, overreliance on these systems can lead to problems, from spreading misinformation to making flawed decisions based on AI recommendations.
It's crucial to use LLMs as one tool among many, supplementing rather than replacing human judgment. Even with the most advanced models, human judgment remains essential for safe and ethical LLM use.
To mitigate the risks of overreliance, take the following steps:
- Regularly validate outputs: Verify the accuracy and appropriateness of LLM-generated content.
- Fine-tune models: Continuously fine-tune your models to minimize errors and biases.
- Communicate risks: Transparently educate users about the potential limitations of LLMs and the importance of critical evaluation.
This balanced approach ensures that LLMs are helpful aids rather than infallible solutions.
Tip 10: Secure your models against theft
LLMs are valuable assets, making them prime targets for theft and unauthorized use. Protecting these assets involves more than just encryption and access controls. It requires:
- Technical safeguards: Implement robust encryption, access controls, and secure technologies.
- Security culture: Conduct regular security audits and foster a culture of data protection through employee training.
Conclusion
Securing LLMs requires careful, continuous work. Here’s a recap of the top 10 tips that show specific ways to strengthen LLM security:
- Tip 1: Safeguard against prompt injection
- Tip 2: Ensure secure output handling
- Tip 3: Prevent data and model poisoning
- Tip 4: Protect against model Denial of Service (DoS) attacks
- Tip 5: Address supply-chain vulnerabilities
- Tip 6: Minimize sensitive information disclosure
- Tip 7: Design secure plugins with care
- Tip 8: Limit excessive agency in LLMs
- Tip 9: Avoid overreliance on LLMs
- Tip 10: Secure your models against theft
These steps cover most of what is needed to keep these advanced systems secure: checking inputs and outputs, avoiding data issues, handling the risk of overload, managing plugins carefully, and keeping a close eye on who can access the models and how they're used.
In short, keeping LLMs secure is about ensuring these powerful tools do a lot of good without opening the door to potential harm. By taking a thorough approach to security, as suggested by the OWASP Top 10 for LLMs and the specific advice given, everyone involved can help ensure LLMs are a positive force in technology, now and in the future.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
- Why is securing LLMs important?
Securing LLMs is crucial to preventing data breaches, unauthorized access, and misuse of these powerful tools. As LLMs handle vast amounts of data, including sensitive information, they ensure their security and protect both the integrity of the models and users' privacy.
- How can I safeguard against prompt injection attacks?
To protect against prompt injection, limit your AI's capabilities, closely examine all inputs for anything unusual, keep AI interactions compartmentalized, and maintain oversight where human judgment can overrule AI decisions.
- What measures can prevent data and model poisoning?
Preventing data and model poisoning involves verifying the legitimacy of your training data sources, using sandboxing to test data in a secure environment, and employing diverse datasets to ensure balanced and accurate AI outputs.
- How can I protect my LLM from Denial of Service (DoS) attacks?
Defend against DoS attacks by implementing rate-limiting to control request numbers, setting resource usage limits for each query, and efficiently managing your action queue to prevent system overload.
- What are some best practices for addressing supply-chain vulnerabilities?
Address supply-chain vulnerabilities by carefully vetting sources and suppliers, conducting vulnerability scans during development and before deployment, using verified package repositories, and maintaining strict oversight through regular security reviews.
- How can sensitive information disclosure be minimized?
Integrating data sanitization and validation processes, controlling data access and sharing through secure data handling protocols, and educating users on safe interactions with LLMs can minimize sensitive information disclosure.
- What steps can be taken to secure models against theft?
Securing models against theft involves creating a security-focused culture within your organization, conducting regular security audits, training employees on data privacy, and utilizing the latest security technologies to protect intellectual and data investments.
- How can I avoid overrelying on LLMs?
Avoid overreliance on LLMs by using them as one of many tools in your toolkit, supplementing rather than replacing human judgment. Regularly validate their outputs and maintain awareness of their limitations to ensure a balanced approach.
Other posts
Understanding and Implementing the NIST AI Risk Management Framework (RMF) with WhyLabs
Dec 10, 2024
- AI risk management
- AI Observability
- AI security
- NIST RMF implementation
- AI compliance
- AI risk mitigation
Best Practicies for Monitoring and Securing RAG Systems in Production
Oct 8, 2024
- Retrival-Augmented Generation (RAG)
- LLM Security
- Generative AI
- ML Monitoring
- LangKit
How to Evaluate and Improve RAG Applications for Safe Production Deployment
Jul 17, 2024
- AI Observability
- LLMs
- LLM Security
- LangKit
- RAG
- Open Source
WhyLabs Integrates with NVIDIA NIM to Deliver GenAI Applications with Security and Control
Jun 2, 2024
- AI Observability
- Generative AI
- Integrations
- LLM Security
- LLMs
- Partnerships
7 Ways to Evaluate and Monitor LLMs
May 13, 2024
- LLMs
- Generative AI
How to Distinguish User Behavior and Data Drift in LLMs
May 7, 2024
- LLMs
- Generative AI
